No matter how many times you go over it, Jim thinks your facts are not the real facts.
I admit I find it fascinating that anyone who graduated the eight grade would argue that if poor persons are paying less tax because their incomes went down, then they should pay more tax; likewise, if rich people are paying more tax because their incomes went up, then they should pay less.
It's so flawed and puerile that it isn't even worth responding to.
I always wondered what that red-faced kid in college economics had written as an essay answer to merit a D- written boldly in magic marker on the top of his test.
Now I know.