Sunday, March 8, 2009

While their may once have been a time when Wall Street could have been considered the engine of American finance, it has become in actual practice little but a high-fashion casino. (Perhaps Bernie Madoff made it too explicit, but in reality his Ponzi scheme functioned for so long, and with so little investigation, precisely because it did operate much as any of the other high-roller operations that it mimicked.) Credit default swaps (at least, as they were implemented) served exactly one purpose, which was to give uninvolved parties a roundabout way to bet large amounts of money on something that was, due to the inherently untangleable mess of the underlying "assets", of unknowable value. Like much of the financial inventions of the last decade or two, it did nothing to stimulate any part of the economy other than finance itself. It created no jobs, except the jobs required to push paperwork from one desk to another. It created no new products, and invented no new technologies, and it gave no money to any party interested in doing either. And America boomed because of it.
That is the nature of the new kind of "finance" that continued to represent a larger and larger share of America's ostensible "prosperity". We have become a nation incapable of effectively making textiles, cars, steel, electronics or other physical things, because those things only allow for a little profit. Instead, we choose to dabble in the strictly theoretical profits of high finance -- imaginary profits on imaginary wealth. Finance became more and more speculatory, and less and less encumbered by physical products, or assets, or services.
And the rich have done exceedingly well for themselves, in that new economy. As for the rest of the nation, the middle class found themselves subjectively in a recession for the entirety of the Bush years. Food prices, gas prices, housing prices -- on every front, it became harder and harder for the middle and poorer classes simply maintain the status quo, and yet none of this counted as recession or poverty, because we simply kept redefining the terms to exclude such unpleasantness.
What did we gain? Ask yourself -- what, exactly, did the nation create during those years? What new projects did America embark on? What betterments did we make to the lives, or health, or happiness of our citizens? What did we do?
The answer is jack-squat

4 comments:

Jim G. said...

Capital Markets are the fertilizer of any economy. A free people can chose whatever occupation they wish, however as I read that piece, I'm thinking, sounds like they are describing lawyers!


How about..the Internet, Housing, Shopping Malls?

The writer conveniently ignores the general high standard of living in this country. Too much food, not too little is generally the problem. Most have access to communication, transportation and education.

We are fortunate to live in a generous, wonderful society, built in part on the fruits of the capital markets.

Baxter said...

It was either Vanderbilt or Carnegie who pointed out that capitalism's chief components are labor, management and capital - each as as important as each leg of a three legged stool.

Mark R. said...

It is hard to comment on such a rambling piece of uninformed pap.

Please provide some back up for your rambling diatribe instead of just reworking a rant that you read on the Huffington Post.

All of these financial instruments you discuss were put in place to spread risk. The risk came from all the crap mortgages that Barney and Chris rammed down the banking systems throat. It appears that they did what they were designed to do since they have managed to cripple the entire fininacial structure.

When a forest fire starts who or what is to blame? Is it the thing that caused the first spark that turns into fire or is it the dry trees themselves that are to blame? We need to correct the genesis of this mess which is the undercollateralized loans and not reward bad behavior by bailing everyone out. If we do not than you can bet that we will find ouselves going over this precipice again.

Baxter said...

Mark -

Do you ever get thrown out of sporting events?

:)